From Invisible Work to Recognised Value

Written by Dr Lucy Hatt and Dr Kelly Smith

This blog is the second in a series of three arising from discussions during and reflections after a REntEd SIG ISBE/EEUK webinar called “Research vs Scholarship”. 

There is a particular kind of professional struggle that education focused academics know well. At certain points in the year, you make a list of what you’ve done and realise that most of it won’t fit easily into the boxes on your performance review or promotion form.  Or, worse still, you don’t even add things to your list, because you don’t count them as legitimate work. University templates for performance review or promotion application for example, are often designed by and for Research focussed academics.  This makes sense from one perspective as those folk are in a significant majority in most research rich Universities.  But it means that it’s less clear, if you’re not a Research focussed academic, how to record activities like curriculum redesign, industry partnership, pastoral work with students who are struggling, the talk you gave at someone else’s conference, the toolkit you wrote, the teaching case-study you co-authored with two colleagues… 

All too often, this type of work can feel trivial when lined up next to a list of highly cited four-star journal articles, huge funding awards and lots of PhD completions. 

More reasons why it’s easy to under report Scholarship activities 

There are several reasons why Scholarship activities are under reported, and consequently undervalued.  Scholarship doesn’t have the same well-defined and widely used metrics as Research. Describing qualitative Scholarship impact takes more words than the more quantifiable Research impact, and often word counts are insufficient to describe Scholarship impact adequately. Perhaps Fields names on Forms only make sense in a traditional Research context and there’s likely no Scholarship equivalent. Lastly, you yourself probably under-report because we operate in a context where our Scholarship contributions are less visible and are articulated less often. We can forget and undervalue the things we do habitually because they are habitual. 

So many people just under-report what they do because they forget about it, or there’s no common language to describe it. 

Make your case 

Before you make your case, whether that’s just your own need to justify how you have spent your time or for a job or promotion application or a performance review, you need to know what your case is.  

We have found a couple of resources that we think are particularly helpful here. 

The first is Appendix B of Braxton, Luckey & Helland (2002) — the Inventory of Scholarship. The whole publication is worth a read of course, but Appendix B from page 140 is a particularly useful resource.  It is a long, structured list of scholarly activities organised against Boyer’s four domains (1990). The list may legitimise activities you have been doing for ever without ever calling them “Scholarship”. 

The second is the DARSHE framework (Gann & Hulme, 2025) — which stands for Description of Activities Relating to Scholarship in Higher Education. DARSHE organises scholarship into four domains: delivering higher education, evidence-informed higher education, sharing higher education practices, and knowledge generation, evaluation and impact.   The categories may be useful for you if you can’t find what you need on Luckey & Halland’s (2002) list. 

By making connections between your work and the literature, it becomes more visible to you and is more legitimate in your work context.  Once you have an inventory of your work described in a way that is grounded in the Scholarship literature, the question becomes, “How do I describe these activities in language that my institution recognises?”  

Build evidence as you go 

The other main reason we think Scholarship work can get under-recognised is that we often don’t have a sufficiently rigorous approach to collecting evidence. By the time you sit down to write a promotion application the email from the student who said your module changed her life is buried; the feedback from the keynote three years ago has gone or was never written down; and the link to the open resource you co-created has stopped working. 

Our advice is to record everything, somehow, all the time. You could use an email folder, a word document or whatever works for you to regularly write up and save evidence of your Scholarship activity.  This will mean that you have it all sitting there ready to be edited to suit when you need it, rather than having to make a case from scratch when you are up against a deadline. 

  • Save thank-you and well-done emails.  
  • Note attendance numbers, not just event titles.  Create mini-satisfaction polls for everything.  Use polls before and after events so you can measure your impact.   
  • Keep a running list of publications, comments on and citations of your work if it’s in the public domain – be that in policy, with professional bodies or in sector blogs for example. 
  • Track invitations even if you said no. 
  • If you’re not sure whether to record something, make a note of it anyway.  You can always decide not to include it later. 

What impact did our webinar have? 

In our recent webinar for the REntEd SIG (EEUK / ISBE), participants’ average score on “I understand what I need to demonstrate to achieve the recognition I am looking for” rose from 3.0 to 4.1 out of 5. We are going to record that in our own inventories of Scholarship activity. 

You can access the webinar slide deck here. 

Find out more 

Dr Kelly Smith and Dr Lucy Hatt have also created a companion one-page guide to give you a starting point using three lenses (contract, progression, identity) supported by some useful frameworks and reflective questions designed to help you start making your case. 

In our third and final post in this series we consider the deeper move beneath all of this: deciding what you actually want to be known for.